Skip to main content
History & heritage

The Kamboja Mahajanapada and where it lay

By The SaathiSutra Team 7 min read
A plain burgundy card with a thin gold border, the words “Kamboj History & Heritage” in cream lettering and “SaathiSutra” in small gold capitals beneath.

Kamboja closes the Buddhist list of sixteen great realms, straight after Gandhara. Where exactly it lay is one of the longest-running arguments in Indian historical geography.

Kamboja was one of the sixteen great realms, the mahajanapadas, in the list the Buddhist canon repeats, and it is the last name on that list, straight after Gandhara. The texts put it in the far north-west, beyond Gandhara, in the northern region the Pali texts call Uttarapatha. Its exact location has never been settled. The candidate areas lie on both sides of the Hindu Kush, from the Kabul valley and Nuristan to Badakhshan and the Pamirs, with Kandahar and the hills south of Kashmir also proposed.

This article covers what the texts say about the realm, the cities they connect with it, each location scholars have argued for, and one popular claim, that the Kambojas once ruled Kashmir, which does not survive a reading of the chronicle it is supposed to come from. For the people themselves, start with who the ancient Kambojas were.

The list of sixteen great realms

The list appears in the Anguttara Nikaya, one of the main collections of the Buddha’s discourses. In one discourse the Buddha uses it to make a point about values: ruling all sixteen realms would be worth less than a sixteenth part of keeping the eight-factored observance day. The list ends, in the Pali, “… gandhārānaṁ, kambojānaṁ”: of the Gandharas, of the Kambojas. The same list comes back in three more discourses of the collection, and each time Kamboja closes it.

The list is not perfectly fixed. The Pali edition on SuttaCentral reads Vanga as the eighth name, where T. W. Rhys Davids printed Vamsa. Rhys Davids also noticed that the sixteen are named after peoples rather than territories, as though the list still thought in tribes. The Jain Bhagavati Sutra has a list of sixteen of its own that leaves out both Gandhara and Kamboja; H. C. Raychaudhuri argued that its wider horizon makes it later, and preferred the Buddhist list as the better picture of the period.

What the texts say about the realm

The Pali texts place Kamboja, like Gandhara, in Uttarapatha, outside the Buddhist “middle country”. In the Assalayana Sutta the Buddha mentions the Yona and Kamboja lands as places with only two classes, masters and servants, between which a person could move. One modern translator renders Kamboja there as Persia, but that is his interpretation: the Pali says Kamboja.

Kautilya’s Arthashastra describes the Kambojas in its book on corporate groups. In R. P. Kangle’s translation of 11.1.4: “The Kambojas, the Surastras, the Ksatriyas, the Srenis and others live by an economic vocation and the profession of arms.” Kangle read this as people who farm and trade in peacetime and take up arms when needed, and judged that the Kamboja group had not gone much beyond a clan, unlike the groups in the next sutra whose leaders took the title raja. R. Shamasastry’s older translation divides the same Sanskrit compound differently, as warrior corporations of Kamboja and Surashtra. In a note elsewhere Kangle calls Kamboja an ancient kingdom north of Gandhara.

Raychaudhuri traced a change over time. The Vedic texts know a Kamboja teacher but no Kamboja king; the Mahabharata gives a Kamboja king, Sudakshina; and later sources, the Arthashastra among them, describe a corporate form of government. The realm was famous for its horses, and the epic’s tribute lists add woollen goods, skins, fine blankets and camels.

The cities the texts connect with Kamboja

Rajapura. In the Mahabharata, Bhishma reminds Karna that he went to Rajapura and slew the Kambojas there; in the critical edition the line reads “karṇa rājapuraṃ gatvā kāmbojā nihatās tvayā”. The verse ties Rajapura to the Kambojas without calling it their capital. Raychaudhuri inferred that it was probably their chief city and identified it with the Rajapura that the Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang visited, south of Punch. Alexander Cunningham had identified Xuanzang’s Rajapura with Rajauri decades earlier, without connecting it to the Kambojas at all; that step is Raychaudhuri’s.

Dvaraka. In the Petavatthu, a Pali collection of stories, merchants travelling to Kamboja to bring back wealth plan to carry a spirit off to Dvaraka, and the commentary on the story calls Dvaravati a Kamboja city. Rhys Davids took this to mean Dvaraka was the capital. Raychaudhuri thought Dvaraka lay outside Kamboja on a road leading to it, G. P. Malalasekera suspected another name was meant, and Moti Chandra suggested Darwaz, north of Badakhshan.

Raychaudhuri also pointed to Nandinagara as a Kamboja city, on the strength of two inscriptions in Heinrich Lüders’ list.

The places scholars have put it

Moti Chandra, surveying the debate in 1945, called Kamboja a will-o’-the-wisp that scholars had moved from Tibet to Afghanistan to the hills south of Kashmir. The main positions are these.

  • The Rajauri and Punch hills south-west of Kashmir: H. C. Raychaudhuri, on the strength of Rajapura. Against it, Jayachandra Vidyalankar argued that the region’s ancient names were Abhisara and Urasa; Raychaudhuri himself conceded that the Mahabharata names Kamboja and Abhisara separately; and the Kashmir chronicle records the rulers of Rajapuri as a Khasa family.
  • Badakhshan and the Pamirs, north of the Hindu Kush: Jayachandra Vidyalankar and Moti Chandra, who pointed to the verb for “to go” that Yaska noticed among the Kambojas surviving in the Pamir languages, and to the epic’s Paramakambojas, the “further Kambojas”.
  • Nuristan, the former Kafiristan, and Kapisa in the southern Hindu Kush: Sylvain Lévi, with Raychaudhuri holding that Kamboja’s western limits reached Kafiristan.
  • The Kandahar region: Émile Benveniste and Paul Bernard, from the Greek and Aramaic Ashokan inscriptions found there. Against it, Fabrizio Maniscalco stresses that no inscription from Kandahar names the Kambojas at all. The evidence is set out in the article on Ashoka’s edicts.
  • The Kabul valley: E. Hultzsch, and R. K. Mookerji as cited by Malalasekera. Aurel Stein, more broadly, put the Kamboja country in eastern Afghanistan.

Did the Kambojas rule Kashmir?

The claim turns up often and is usually credited to Kalhana’s Rajatarangini, the chronicle of the kings of Kashmir. In Aurel Stein’s translation of 1900 the chronicle mentions the Kambojas exactly once. Describing King Lalitaditya’s campaign into the north, Kalhana writes: “The stables of the Kāmbojas were emptied of horses.” The Kambojas appear as a northern people raided by a king of Kashmir, not as its rulers, and Stein warned that Kalhana’s account of these campaigns is a mixture of history and legend.

The Rajauri route does not rescue the claim either. In the chronicle, Rajapuri is a hill state ruled by a Khasa family, and Cunningham’s identification of Rajapura with Rajauri said nothing about the Kambojas. No source we could find shows Kamboja rule over Kashmir, so this article does not repeat it.

What the evidence supports

Kamboja lay beyond Gandhara, to the north or north-west, in the northern region of the old routes. Every serious candidate lies in the mountain country on either side of the Hindu Kush, and the epic already knew of Kambojas further out still. It was a realm famous for its horses, organised at some periods as a corporate group rather than a monarchy, and known to the Ganges heartland as a frontier land with different customs. Raychaudhuri also insisted on keeping it apart from Bahlika, which is Bactria, and from Kambuja, the old name of Cambodia, which is a different place.

What is still debated

  • The location itself. Five regions have serious advocates and none is proven.
  • Whether Rajapura was the capital. The epic links it to the Kambojas; calling it their capital is Raychaudhuri’s inference.
  • Whether Dvaraka was a Kamboja city at all. It rests on one commentary, and three scholars have read it differently.
  • How to read the Arthashastra’s compound: Kambojas and Surashtras alongside kshatriyas and shrenis, or warrior corporations of Kamboja and Surashtra.
  • Whether Kamboja counted as part of India in the Buddha’s time. Moti Chandra called it a debatable question.

Sources

  1. Anguttara Nikaya 3.70, 8.42, 8.43 and 8.45, Pali text with translation by Bhikkhu Sujato — SuttaCentral

    The list of sixteen great realms ending with Gandhara and Kamboja, quoted above in the Pali.

  2. Majjhima Nikaya 93 (Assalayana Sutta) and Petavatthu 2.9, Pali text — SuttaCentral

    The Yona and Kamboja lands with only two classes, and the merchants travelling to Kamboja in the story of Ankura.

  3. R. P. Kangle, The Kautiliya Arthasastra, Part II: English translation with notes, 2nd edition (1972) — University of Bombay

    The translation of 11.1.4 quoted above, Kangle’s reading of the Kambojas as a clan-level corporate group, and his note placing Kamboja north of Gandhara.

  4. Mahabharata, critical edition, Sabhaparvan and Dronaparvan (electronic text) — Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, via GRETIL, Göttingen

    Rajapura and the Kambojas (7.4.4), quoted above, Arjuna’s northern conquest with the Kambojas and the Paramakambojas (2.24), and the tribute lists.

  5. H. C. Raychaudhuri, Political History of Ancient India, 5th edition (1950), pp. 96, 148–150 — University of Calcutta

    The Rajapura and Rajauri argument and its difficulties, Kafiristan, Nandinagara, the doubts about Dvaraka, the change from kings to a corporate form, the Jain list, and the separation from Bahlika and Kambuja.

  6. A. Cunningham, The Ancient Geography of India, vol. I (1871), pp. 129–130 — Trübner, London

    The identification of Xuanzang’s Rajapura with Rajauri, made without reference to the Kambojas.

  7. T. W. Rhys Davids, Buddhist India (1903), pp. 23–28 — T. Fisher Unwin, London

    The sixteen realms as names of peoples, the variant eighth name, and Dvaraka read as the capital.

  8. G. P. Malalasekera, Dictionary of Pali Proper Names, vol. I (1937), s.v. Kamboja and Dvaravati — John Murray, for the Government of India

    Kamboja in Uttarapatha with Gandhara, the doubt over Dvaraka, and Mookerji’s Kabul placing.

  9. Moti Chandra, Geographical and Economic Studies in the Mahabharata: Upayana Parva (1945), pp. 36–39 — U.P. Historical Society, Lucknow

    The survey of proposed locations, the Pamir and Badakhshan case, Jayachandra Vidyalankar’s objections, and Darwaz.

  10. M. A. Stein (trans.), Kalhana’s Rajatarangini: A Chronicle of the Kings of Kasmir, vols. I–II (1900) — Archibald Constable, Westminster

    The single mention of the Kambojas at IV.165, quoted above, Stein’s warning about Lalitaditya’s campaigns, his placing of Kamboja in eastern Afghanistan, and the Khasa rulers of Rajapuri.

  11. F. Maniscalco, “A New Interpretation of the Edicts of Asoka from Kandahar”, Annali di Ca’ Foscari, Serie orientale 54 (2018), pp. 239–264 — Edizioni Ca’ Foscari

    The Kandahar theory as held by Benveniste and Bernard, and the objection that no Kandahar inscription names the Kambojas.

  12. E. Hultzsch, Inscriptions of Asoka, Corpus Inscriptionum Indicarum vol. I, new edition (1925) — Clarendon Press, Oxford

    Hultzsch’s placing of the Kambojas in the Kabul region.

Our team answers every message. Reach out and we will sort it out.