Skip to main content
History & heritage

Bhai Mani Singh: scribe, granthi and martyr

By The SaathiSutra Team 7 min read
A plain burgundy card with a thin gold border, the words “Kamboj History & Heritage” in cream lettering and “SaathiSutra” in small gold capitals beneath.

The companion of Guru Gobind Singh who kept the Harimandar at Amritsar, is remembered as a scribe and compiler, and was executed at Lahore in the 1730s. Three old sources give him three different castes, one of them Kamboj; this article sets out all three.

Bhai Mani Singh is one of the most honoured figures of eighteenth-century Sikh history. He grew up beside the future Guru Gobind Singh, took the Khalsa vows, served as granthi, the keeper and reader of the scripture, at the Harimandar in Amritsar, and is remembered by tradition as the scribe of the scripture at Damdama and the compiler of the Tenth Guru’s writings. In the 1730s he was put to death at Lahore by the Mughal governor of the Punjab after refusing to give up his faith.

He matters to Kamboj families because the earliest source to name his caste, Kesar Singh Chhibbar’s Bansavalinama of 1769, calls him a Kamboh. Two later sources give him a different family, and the historians who have studied the question have not settled it. This article sets out what each source says, using the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, the edited texts themselves and the Historical Dictionary of Sikhism by Louis Fenech and W. H. McLeod. His family is also tied by one tradition to Bhai Dayala, who died with Guru Tegh Bahadur in 1675.

The three accounts of his family

The sources disagree about where he was born, when, and into which family. Each account is given here with the person who put it forward.

  • Kamboh. Kesar Singh Chhibbar, of the Chhibbar Brahman family, completed his Bansavalinama in 1769. Twice he describes Mani Singh as a Kamboh by caste, in the original “jati Kamboh” and “jati Kambou”, and he says he himself saw Mani Singh’s circle at Amritsar. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism reports this as Chhibbar’s statement and calls Chhibbar his contemporary. Against it, the scholar Giani Garja Singh argued in 1961 that Chhibbar was only a small child in the 1720s, so he may have been mistaken or have meant another Mani Singh.
  • Dullat Jat of Kamboval, near Sunam. This is the account of the chronicler Giani Gian Singh, which the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism attributes to some later chroniclers following him. Fenech and McLeod’s dictionary, which calls him a Jat Sikh born near Patiala in 1673, gives no source but is in line with it. Garja Singh objected that Gian Singh changed his account between editions, claimed Mani Singh as his own ancestor, and cited no source; by Garja Singh’s reading, Gian Singh’s first edition spoke of two Mani Singhs, one of them a Kamboh.
  • Panwar (Parmar) Rajput of Alipur, near Multan. This is the account of the Shahid Bilas, a verse life attributed to Seva Singh and published by Garja Singh in 1961 with family records kept by bards and priests. It makes him Mani Ram, the third of the twelve sons of Mai Das, born in 1644. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism’s own entry on the work, by Harnam Singh Shan, says this account has not yet won firm acceptance: the original manuscript does not survive, its dates differ from other chroniclers, and the question awaits further research. Fenech and McLeod date the work to the early nineteenth century.

Which of the three is right is not known. A Kamboj family can say, accurately, that the oldest source to name his caste calls him a Kamboh, and that two other traditions give him other families.

With Guru Gobind Singh

According to the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism he was brought as a small child to Guru Tegh Bahadur at Anandpur and grew up with the young Gobind Singh; the historian Harbans Singh records that the future Guru had a classmate called Maniya. He went with the Guru to Paonta and took the Khalsa vows when the order was founded in 1699. Soon afterwards, in the encyclopaedia’s account, the Guru sent him to take charge of the Harimandar at Amritsar, which had been without a custodian since 1696.

When the Guru left Anandpur in December 1705 he escorted Mata Sundari and Mata Sahib Devan to Delhi. In 1706 he rejoined the Guru at Talwandi Sabo, now Damdama Sahib, where, the encyclopaedia says, he wrote out the final recension of the scripture under the Guru’s guidance. Fenech and McLeod treat this as tradition rather than established fact.

Scribe and compiler

Several writings are linked to his name, and scholars treat the links with different degrees of caution:

  • The Dasam Granth. The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism calls its compilation his chief literary work; Fenech and McLeod say the Tenth Guru’s writings are believed, by tradition, to have been collected by him in the two decades after 1708. Chhibbar tells of him gathering the scattered leaves at Amritsar in 1725 and binding them into one volume with the Adi Granth.
  • A manuscript of the scripture known by his name and dated about 1713. Some scholars accept the date; others, as J. S. Grewal reports, doubt it.
  • A letter dated 1711 to Mata Sundari about gathering the Tenth Guru’s compositions. The encyclopaedia says it survives; Grewal reports Ratan Singh Jaggi’s argument that it is a later forgery.
  • The Gian Ratanavali, a life of the first Sikh Guru, and the Bhagat Ratanavali, on the devotees named by Bhai Gurdas. McLeod calls the first a traditional attribution; Fenech and McLeod’s dictionary calls it wrongly attributed, an Udasi work of the early nineteenth century, and the second unreliably attributed.

Granthi at Amritsar

After the execution of Banda Singh Bahadur the Sikhs were split between Banda’s followers and the Tat Khalsa. Harbans Singh and Fenech and McLeod say Mata Sundari placed Mani Singh in charge of the Harimandar, and the encyclopaedia says he used his influence to make peace between the two sides. The editor of the Bansavalinama, Raejasbir Singh, dates the settlement to the Vaisakhi of 1721; the later chronicler Ratan Singh Bhangu, as Grewal summarises him, tells of lots cast into the sacred pool and a contest, after which Mani Singh took over the seat the other party had set up. Harbans Singh records that he presided at the initiation of Kapur Singh at a Diwali gathering.

His death at Lahore

In the encyclopaedia’s account he asked the governor of Lahore, Zakariya Khan, for leave to hold the Diwali gathering at Amritsar. It was granted on payment of a tax of 5,000 rupees, which Bhangu gives as 10,000. Learning that the governor secretly meant to attack the gathering, he told the Sikhs not to come, and the tax went unpaid. After a summary trial he was given the choice of accepting Islam or dying, refused, and was executed at Lahore; the sources say his body was cut apart at the joints. Fenech and McLeod call the charge of failing to pay tribute a pretext and name Lakhpat Rai, Zakariya Khan’s chief minister, as responsible. Chhibbar, who gives no date, writes that he had done the rulers no wrong.

The place of execution in Lahore was marked by Gurdwara Shahidganj until 1947. The encyclopaedia notes that a memorial gurdwara has been built in recent decades at the ruined site of Kamboval, near Sunam.

What is still debated

  • His caste: Kamboh in Chhibbar, Dullat Jat in Gian Singh, Panwar Rajput in the Shahid Bilas. No source has settled it.
  • The year of his death: 1734 in the Shahid Bilas, 1737 in the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, 1738 in Gian Singh’s Twarikh Guru Khalsa, Raejasbir Singh and Fenech and McLeod.
  • His birth: 1644 in the Shahid Bilas, 1673 in Fenech and McLeod.
  • Who sent him to Amritsar, and when: the Guru soon after 1699, or Mata Sundari after Banda’s death.
  • How much of the writing linked to him is his. The Damdama recension and the Dasam Granth compilation are tradition; the Gian Ratanavali is now widely thought to be later.
  • Whether Bhai Dayala was his brother. The Shahid Bilas and Fenech and McLeod say so; it fits the Alipur family of the Shahid Bilas better than a family near Patiala.

Sources

  1. Gurmukh Singh, “Mani Singh, Bhai (d. 1737)”, The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, ed. Harbans Singh — Punjabi University, Patiala

    His life with Guru Gobind Singh, Damdama, the Harimandar, the peace between the parties, the Diwali tax, his execution, and the Kamboh and Dullat accounts.

  2. Harnam Singh Shan, “Shahid Bilas (Bhai Mani Singh)”, The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism — Punjabi University, Patiala

    The Panwar Rajput account, its dates, and the scholarly caution about it.

  3. W. H. McLeod, “Mani Singh Janam Sakhi”, The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism — Punjabi University, Patiala

    The attribution of the Gian Ratanavali and its manuscripts.

  4. Kesar Singh Chhibbar, Bansavalinama Dasan Patshahian Ka (1769), ed. Raejasbir Singh (2001), 10.381–387, 13.20, 14.86, 14.191 — Amritsar, 2001

    The two lines calling him a Kamboh, the binding of the Tenth Guru’s writings, his death, Chhibbar’s own sight of him, and the editor’s dates for 1721 and 1738.

  5. Seva Singh, Shahid Bilas Bhai Mani Singh, ed. Giani Garja Singh (1961) — Punjabi Sahit Akademi, Ludhiana

    The Alipur family, the 1644 and 1734 dates, Dial Das as his brother, and Garja Singh’s objections to the other two accounts.

  6. Louis E. Fenech and W. H. McLeod, Historical Dictionary of Sikhism, 3rd ed. (2014), pp. 64, 92–95, 141, 175, 199, 282 — Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham

    Dates of 1673–1738, the attributions treated as tradition, Lakhpat Rai, Dayal Das as his elder brother, Chhibbar and the Shahid Bilas.

  7. Harbans Singh, The Heritage of the Sikhs (1964), pp. 37, 52 — Asia Publishing House, Bombay

    The classmate Maniya, his appointment by Mata Sundari and the initiation of Kapur Singh.

  8. J. S. Grewal, History, Literature, and Identity: Four Centuries of Sikh Tradition (2011), pp. 246–247, 261 — Oxford University Press, New Delhi

    Chhibbar’s account of the binding and the martyrdom, and Bhangu’s account of the dispute at Amritsar.

  9. J. S. Grewal, Contesting Interpretations of the Sikh Tradition (1998), pp. 261–263 — Manohar, New Delhi

    Jaggi on the 1711 letter and the debate over the manuscript dated 1713.

Our team answers every message. Reach out and we will sort it out.